Regression: Hydrogen bug, thrusters on same conveyor network stop working when a single tank is lost

Muzzled shared this bug 2 years ago
Reported

This bug was fixed as of the warfare 2 update, but has since re-emerged as a regression. Previous post I made about this bug here:

https://support.keenswh.com/spaceengineers/pc/topic/22631-hydrogen-bug-hydrogen-thrusters-continue-to-work-without-a-connection-or-all-thrusters-stop-working


Steps to reproduce;

Load an unmodified world in creative mode (for ease of testing, this works in survival).

1) Connect two hydrogen tanks with a conveyor.

2) Connect two hydrogen thrusters, one to each tank.

3) Observe them being functional.

4) Remove one of the tanks.


Depending on random chance (?) the thruster that was connected to the tank you removed will anomalously continue to function, or will cause the unrelated thruster to cease functioning. Attached are some screenshots showing the issue, a webm demonstrating the process, and the world file as a zip. It seems the entire hydrogen network will "choose" a particular hydrogen tank. If this tank is destroyed or removed the whole network will shut down until the grid is cut and pasted or the tank is replaced.


This issue scales up to larger ships, happens in survival, happens in single player, happens in multiplayer, happens on dedicated servers, happens after damage events with weapons, happens with modded weapons and thrusters. I appears to be triggered by using more than one port on the hydrogen tank. If you do not directly connect the hydrogen tanks via their resource ports the issue is more difficult to reproduce. You can use this bug to abuse hydrogen thrusters with hydrogen-at-a-distance if you're dedicated but its unlikely to be very useful.

Replies (8)

photo
3

Hello, Muzzled,

thanks for letting us know.

Yes, you are right, Unfortunately this issue is back and from your files, I was able to reproduce it.

Did put this issue to our internal system.

Kind Regards

Keen Software House: QA Department

photo
1

Well maaaybe they can also look into fixing this while digging into that code...

https://support.keenswh.com/spaceengineers/pc/topic/custom-gas-thrusters-can-run-on-hydrogen-and-vice-versa

photo
photo
1

Keen when will you expect, this to be fixet?. we still see the error.

photo
2

Have a similar issue, thrusters stop sucking hydrogen out of tanks randomly and after few seconds stop working completely

photo
1

Well this has been a problem for a long time now can we please get it fix soon, as it's a big problem making ships.

photo
1

https://youtu.be/uRH-yadX3Cs

https://youtu.be/IQUm5z5MBwo

These are reproducing bug video I record. (version:1.201.014 / 2023.03.21)

photo
1

I made a failproof blueprint to explain this but they redirected me to this 13 months old thread

photo
2

yeah we are still wating for them to fix it, but it has been a year now and they have not fix it yet. They fix it ones with the warfare 2 update but then they broke it again with a hotfix.


I work in a software company and if we found a problem this bad we have fix it the same day or the day after, we have not wated a year or longer to fix, a problem this bad.

photo
2

the worst part is that they don't communicate about it so we don't even know if they try to fix it.

photo
1

There seems to be a related issue. I noticed that deleting or damaging a certain conveyor, usually the last one connected to a thruster, kills the whole ship. I was told to check if the bug persists after they fix this one.

photo
1

2 years now, i wonder how many more.

photo
photo
1

This is still a big issue. I have a grid that hydrobugs the second you spawn it in, which might help you guys replicate it:

photo
1

Having trouble reproducing it in my usual singleplayer testing setup, creative or survival. The network seems to recover a second or two later and any visual bugs go away whenever the player input is detected through the cockpit. Maybe the signal or automaton update fixed it?

Leave a Comment
 
Attach a file