This object is in archive! 
LIghting colour change by group preset
Not Enough Votes
It would be a great saving to allow the colour of lights to changed/switched with through values stored in a group identity.
If rather than the group just being a means to gather blocks together for an operation, the group itself could store a preset state that could be recalled.
This is a similar idea to the one used for setting hinges and rotors.
Example : a set of lights is grouped as being all red by a group call redlight.
The same set of lights can be in another group called blueflash being set to a flashing blue colour.
An event controller or timer could activate the group triggering the preset state.
Access denied
I like this feedback
Hinges and rotors don't keep state in their group. If you add a new hinge to an existing group it will not automatically pick up a common state to match the hinges already in the group (correct me if I'm wrong here).
Groups allow batch-editing of properties shared by all blocks in the group. When you edit settings for a group, it will only show you the properties common for all blocks in the group, and changing them will directly update the blocks in the group. The settings are not stored on the group itself.
Group settings overriding individual block settings can be very problematic from user-experience perspective. Sure, it will be useful if you want the same settings for all blocks in the group, but what if you don't? Let's take your red lights example, what if you really want all lights to be red, but have each light have distinct intensities. If you edit an individual block and change its settings, how does that interact with the settings saved in the group? Does it create an individual override for that particular block, or does that directly edit the group settings and apply to other adjacent blocks as well? If it edits the group settings, then you simply cannot have your red lights have different intensities, it's only ever going to be one common intensity for the entire group. If it's an override, how do you remove it to default to the group settings again, e.g. if you accidentally change the color of one of your red lights and want to reset it back to the group default? Do you simply edit the group settings and that removes all existing overrides (you can see how that can be problematic as well, resetting potentially tens or hundreds of individual overrides in a single easy step that might be accidental)? Or do you get a separate UI element to remove that override? That can make the interface much more complicated than it needs to be.
Hinges and rotors don't keep state in their group. If you add a new hinge to an existing group it will not automatically pick up a common state to match the hinges already in the group (correct me if I'm wrong here).
Groups allow batch-editing of properties shared by all blocks in the group. When you edit settings for a group, it will only show you the properties common for all blocks in the group, and changing them will directly update the blocks in the group. The settings are not stored on the group itself.
Group settings overriding individual block settings can be very problematic from user-experience perspective. Sure, it will be useful if you want the same settings for all blocks in the group, but what if you don't? Let's take your red lights example, what if you really want all lights to be red, but have each light have distinct intensities. If you edit an individual block and change its settings, how does that interact with the settings saved in the group? Does it create an individual override for that particular block, or does that directly edit the group settings and apply to other adjacent blocks as well? If it edits the group settings, then you simply cannot have your red lights have different intensities, it's only ever going to be one common intensity for the entire group. If it's an override, how do you remove it to default to the group settings again, e.g. if you accidentally change the color of one of your red lights and want to reset it back to the group default? Do you simply edit the group settings and that removes all existing overrides (you can see how that can be problematic as well, resetting potentially tens or hundreds of individual overrides in a single easy step that might be accidental)? Or do you get a separate UI element to remove that override? That can make the interface much more complicated than it needs to be.
Replies have been locked on this page!