This object is in archive! 

Dedicated Design Mode

4Peace shared this feedback 9 months ago
Not Enough Votes

In SE2, developers are improving the building system.

Key improvements for creative building that are already done include:

  1. Unified grid system – no more small vs. large grid choice; you have a single grid where you can place blocks of 3 different sizes: 0.25m, 0.5m, and 2.5m.
  2. Partial copy-paste and blueprinting of selected sections – something previously possible only through mods in SE1.

What has been announced:

  1. Projection Build in Survival, where you can design a grid without components — basically constructing a projection of blocks.



My Concern

I do not like the projection building system shown in the sneak peek.

The blocks appear semi-transparent, using a projection shader that makes building visually confusing and less clear than using fully constructed blocks. Even if the transparency issue could be fixed by adjusting opacity or making them non-transparent, there are still other drawbacks.

In Creative, you can use the Spectator Camera to move freely and reach otherwise inaccessible areas to place or remove blocks.

In Survival, you’re limited by your jetpack — especially in gravity wells — which makes this tool still less convenient than building in a creative world. This defeats the purpose of “not needing to load a creative world” to design your grids, making the feature feel underwhelming and like wasted potential.



Proposed Solution

I propose adding a Dedicated Design Mode instead.

When you enter this mode (either from a Projector Block or a new Design Station — for example, a table with a chair and monitors), the current grid you’re sitting in automatically loads, or you can start from scratch with a completely new grid or a subgrid of the existing one.

You would then see only what you’re building, in a separate virtual space — without other players, grids, planets, or distractions. This would also make it much lighter on performance and more focused on design itself.

In this environment, you wouldn’t fly around as your engineer, but instead use more traditional design-oriented controls — orbiting the grid, panning and zooming with the mouse wheel. This setup would allow room for dedicated tools and a full design interface instead of being limited by the small toolbar at the bottom.



Design Mode Features

A dedicated design mode could include:

  • Full block catalog access with categories, search, and filters.
  • Fill tools: select multiple faces and fill the volume between them with armor blocks, the game will propose the most efficient armor layout using exiting blocks of in correct size and orientation for minimal block count.
  • Shape tools: for making large ramps, planes, rings, spheres, slopes etc. Similar to "fill tool" but with different presets and parameters for the shape
  • Partial copy-paste made much easier and more precise.
  • Access to the blueprint library directly inside the mode.
  • Grid statistics display with details like mass, block count, PCU usage, acceleration, rotation rate, fuel and power capacity, etc.
  • Option to preview grids from your library or the Workshop before placing or building them — even comparing multiple grids side by side.

Once we have this kind of dedicated design environment, the possibilities become endless.



Console and Cooperative Design Considerations

For console players, this new control scheme might be more difficult to adapt, as it’s less suited to controllers. Even if optimized, console players would likely be more limited in what they can do compared to PC users.

As for cooperative design, it would require additional development effort to allow multiple players to work on the same grid in this mode — a feature that’s already technically possible through creative building in SE1 and SE2.


However, I believe the value of a dedicated design tool far outweighs these drawbacks. It would offer a huge step forward for both creativity and usability, making SE2’s building experience truly next-level.

Best Answer
photo

Update after trying the projection building and confrontation with many other players

There are too many gameplay mechanics layered on top of each other in this game. Even as someone with 10+ years of Space Engineers experience, it’s hard to wrap my head around all the controls. For a completely new player, this must be overwhelming.

As a character or pilot you can do many different things:

  • Flying around
  • Projection building
  • Welding or grinding
  • Combat, controlling turrets
  • Controlling mechanical systems

Each of these could be a game on its own. But here we have a common UIs and controls for all those situations, which means it is extremely difficult to do those UIs and controls to be good and intuitive.

On top of that, we’re mixing tools, weapons, consumables, emotes, actions, building blocks, blueprints ( did I forget something? 😄) all on the same toolbar. That’s just too much.

I strongly believe there should be at least a separate mode for projection building, with its own UI and controls.

In that mode:


  • The hotbar should be different and contain only blocks and blueprints
  • The G menu / blueprint menu should be preloaded, so it opens insanely fast and you can easily add things to your hotbar(s).
  • Other related to projection building UIs
  • Projection building dedicated contextual helps

How to activate a “projection build mode”? My favorite idea would be a small drone attached to your backpack.


  • Press a button → the drone launches into the air and the build UI opens automatically.
  • The drone is fast, agile, and small enough to fit anywhere you need.
  • Press the button again → build mode closes, you immediately regain character control, and the drone automatically returns to you.
  • Drone might have a lot of flight time before it needs to be recharged, and when it is low on charge it would return automatically.

Ideally, this drone could be deployed even while sitting in a cockpit or seat, and it could “phase” through some obstacles (cockpit glass, walls) when deploying on top of your character or when returning.

For example:


  • You’re piloting a welder ship.
  • You deploy the drone without exiting the cockpit.
  • You quickly do some projection building.
  • You switch back to your character.
  • The drone flies back to you automatically.

This kind of system is used in many other games, and I think it would fit Space Engineers extremely well.

The drone itself could be crafted in the gearforge and occupy a consumables slot. By default, players could spawn with one—similar to how we currently spawn with basic tools, so it's no issue for FTUE. There might be other, more advanced, craftable drones, plus modded ones ofc.

As a bonus, you now can nerf the overpowered jet-pack on planets 😄


In any case, having a dedicated projection building mode would be more accessible, less confusing, liberate your regular character hotbar from being cluttered with blocks you don't need all the time. With a drone, you can easily fly around your building project, fit through the smallest holes and place projections where you normally would be able to.


Thx for reading. Comment and suggest your alternatives.

Replies (2)

photo
3

Update after trying the projection building and confrontation with many other players

There are too many gameplay mechanics layered on top of each other in this game. Even as someone with 10+ years of Space Engineers experience, it’s hard to wrap my head around all the controls. For a completely new player, this must be overwhelming.

As a character or pilot you can do many different things:

  • Flying around
  • Projection building
  • Welding or grinding
  • Combat, controlling turrets
  • Controlling mechanical systems

Each of these could be a game on its own. But here we have a common UIs and controls for all those situations, which means it is extremely difficult to do those UIs and controls to be good and intuitive.

On top of that, we’re mixing tools, weapons, consumables, emotes, actions, building blocks, blueprints ( did I forget something? 😄) all on the same toolbar. That’s just too much.

I strongly believe there should be at least a separate mode for projection building, with its own UI and controls.

In that mode:


  • The hotbar should be different and contain only blocks and blueprints
  • The G menu / blueprint menu should be preloaded, so it opens insanely fast and you can easily add things to your hotbar(s).
  • Other related to projection building UIs
  • Projection building dedicated contextual helps

How to activate a “projection build mode”? My favorite idea would be a small drone attached to your backpack.


  • Press a button → the drone launches into the air and the build UI opens automatically.
  • The drone is fast, agile, and small enough to fit anywhere you need.
  • Press the button again → build mode closes, you immediately regain character control, and the drone automatically returns to you.
  • Drone might have a lot of flight time before it needs to be recharged, and when it is low on charge it would return automatically.

Ideally, this drone could be deployed even while sitting in a cockpit or seat, and it could “phase” through some obstacles (cockpit glass, walls) when deploying on top of your character or when returning.

For example:


  • You’re piloting a welder ship.
  • You deploy the drone without exiting the cockpit.
  • You quickly do some projection building.
  • You switch back to your character.
  • The drone flies back to you automatically.

This kind of system is used in many other games, and I think it would fit Space Engineers extremely well.

The drone itself could be crafted in the gearforge and occupy a consumables slot. By default, players could spawn with one—similar to how we currently spawn with basic tools, so it's no issue for FTUE. There might be other, more advanced, craftable drones, plus modded ones ofc.

As a bonus, you now can nerf the overpowered jet-pack on planets 😄


In any case, having a dedicated projection building mode would be more accessible, less confusing, liberate your regular character hotbar from being cluttered with blocks you don't need all the time. With a drone, you can easily fly around your building project, fit through the smallest holes and place projections where you normally would be able to.


Thx for reading. Comment and suggest your alternatives.

photo
2

I imagined dedicated seat with cryopod effect on character (be it table with monitors or maybe could look like Cyberpunk Netrunner station!) which takes player to dedicated design mode with tools for full screen design of blueprints.


And a drone is a cool idea for field works (could be FPV with character wearing VR gogles ;).

The character stays "aware", suit consumes energy, hunger, radiation if they will be added etc.

Basically kind of remote control experience but with dedicated controls and HUD.


Phasing through objects could be potential exploit in multiplayer and combat scenarios, so it would need to be protected somehow to act as current 3rd person view with limited distance of control maybe.


I think Subnautica made it quite right with their camera drones. They are very small so can enter places where player can't but are physical objects which can run out of energy, stuck or be attacked (but most predators just ignore them). Same could be in SE - tiny drone, deployed from backpack, but with limited energy, range and physical entity. It could be as tiny as smallest block but still limited by closed hangars, doors, safe zones etc.

photo
3

Another game that I think has a pretty good implementation of this is StarRupture. I also like how you don't start with this option, but have to research it so it's not thrown at you right in the beginning.

photo
1

Yes, I really like how it works in StarRupture. Whenever you want to build something, that drone pops up in the air, and you instantly see what it sees and can easily fly around and build small or big, get close or far away. The drone's movements are much faster and more responsive than if you flew around with the jetpack but still not instant like a spectator camera is, which I don't like either. It feels just perfect. And the best part is you have a dedicated UI for building once you launch it and as soon sas you call it back, you regain control of your character and the drone gets back to you automatically, so you do not waste any time and enjoy the game.

photo
2

The idea of a drone is nice and appealing, But I don't think it could replace a true dedicated design mode.

I'd rather have it, like a tool in survival or a helping buddy, and in the other hand having an in-game workstation or a game mode, to enter in design mode.


To me, such mode should give you full freedom, just pure creation.

The idea would be to be sent into a virtual hangar with just our ship/blueprint. So no cheating with the free camera.


- No physical camera object (passing through blocks), steady and fast camera which stay aligned with the ship's plan (no tilting to weird angles).

- A block picker/pipette tool. Target a block, press A, boom block equipped, ready to place.

- Giving you the possibility to select a big chunk of the ship, nudge it away, add something in between, nudge the chunk back in.

- which could be nice for single object too. Place it, select it, check from afar if placement is good, nudge if necessary, done.

- If there is things not connected with the main grid, show them in red when we try to save the BP.

- coping and pasting chunks on the fly.

- Maybe a library to store said chunks.


And everything else you could think of in a dedicated space !

photo
2

An instanced blueprint "creator" would be great. Paired with the new blueprints system, I think it'd take away most of the existing friction with the current building methods, while not needing to worry about exploitable interaction in multiplayer.

One of the main issues a building mode like this would address as well is just how we tackle the design process particularly when building in atmosphere. That issue being supports, space and interruptions.


Supports being required when building in atmosphere require you to build bottom up, while the bottom tends to be largely inconsequential when it comes to buildings. A design mode would allow us to work top down without friction.

Providing space would become a non-issue as you can grow your design near infinitely while designing. It really allows you to design a blueprint. Designing a structure/vehicle and then meeting the conditions to build it in the environment. At that point after designing you are aware of how much space you need.

Interruptions being Energy and O2 in survival and reducing Menu/Hotbar interaction costs. A dedicated design mode would ideally remedy the friction generated with prolonged build/design instances. Having an always accessible list of parts to select from would remove the majority of the interaction costs that comes with building through hotbars in the environment and designing in a dedicated instance the only maintenance you need to worry about while designing is well... your real life maintenance.

Overall, I very much hope we can see the design experience further iterated on with the goal of providing an efficient and frictionless workspace.

photo
2

Yes, the toolbar is a real bottleneck during building. There is only so much you can add to it, and then you have to remember which block is on which page of the toolbar. And yet, you still cannot fit all the blocks in it. On top of that, you also want some tools, consumables, emojis, etc. All in the same place, covering things related to many different aspects of the game.

Designing grids is one of the most important parts of this game, though. And yet we have this lazy approach when it comes to building tools. A proper edit mode with a camera orbiting around the grid, quick zoom in and out, better block selection with a proper cursor, the whole block library always available, more dedicated building tools and UI... all of this would take building to the next level and make players save an order of magnitude of time.

Instead, we have projection building, which is just an inferior experience by many measures compared to what we even had before in survival. Yes, it now requires no components to lay down the blocks, but I would rather still have hollow frames like before than look at these confusing holograms. And if I want to design something serious, I would enter a proper design session with appropriate tools where I can freely express my creativity.

Yet this idea was archived a long time ago. It feels like the developers are taking a lazy approach here. They made an overpowered jetpack that allows you to easily fly in gravity on battery power for a long time, so you can design your grid with a foggy projection. This mode has so many flaws that I don't think it would ever be any good, tbh.

Whatever shader you use for the projected blocks, they will never be as clear as the actual blocks you see in creative, or the physical frames we had back in SE1. This "experiment" leads nowhere imo. It can't compete with a true dedicated design tool. It only adds more confusion for new players who are already overwhelmed with controls and competing toolbars/modes for everything that exists in the game.

This game desperately needs better building tools. There are countless topics about people complaining about how tedious it is to build things. The approach they took is limited by its nature, and even if they polish it, it will always be a bottleneck preventing you from fully enjoying the building side of the game.

photo
Leave a Comment
 
Attach a file
You can't vote. Please authorize!